Home News

Offshore Crypto Accounts: How Detection Works and What Happens If You Get Caught

Keeping crypto in offshore accounts used to feel like a smart way to stay under the radar. But today, that idea is dangerously outdated. If you think hiding your crypto holdings overseas will keep you safe from regulators, you’re operating on outdated assumptions. The tools to find you are better than ever-and the penalties aren’t just fines anymore. They’re jail time, seized assets, and permanent legal scars.

How They Find Your Offshore Crypto Accounts

You don’t need to be a hacker to get caught. Most people who try to hide crypto offshore make the same basic mistakes. The blockchain doesn’t lie. Every transaction is permanently recorded, and experts have spent years learning how to read it.

One of the most common errors is address reuse. If you use the same Bitcoin or Ethereum address to receive funds multiple times, you’re leaving a trail. Investigators can track every deposit, every withdrawal, and every time that address interacts with an exchange. Even if you think you’re anonymous, the pattern tells the story.

Then there’s address clustering. This isn’t magic-it’s math. When you move funds between multiple wallets, analysts look for patterns: same timing, similar amounts, recurring transfers. If two wallets send money to the same exchange at the same time, they’re likely controlled by the same person. That’s how a dozen "separate" wallets get tied to one person.

Even more telling are peel chains. That’s when someone splits a large crypto amount into smaller pieces, sends them through multiple wallets, then tries to recombine them later. It sounds clever, but it’s a red flag. Automated tools spot this instantly. The more layers you add, the more evidence you create.

And don’t count on mixers or tumblers. Services like Tornado Cash and Blender.io were once popular for hiding transaction origins. But after they were sanctioned by OFAC in 2022, using them became a legal risk in itself. If you send funds through a sanctioned mixer-even once-you’re now flagged. Exchanges automatically block those transactions. Your account gets frozen. Your name goes on a watchlist.

Then there’s IP correlation. If you log into your offshore exchange from your home Wi-Fi, your IP address is logged. Even if you use a VPN, mistakes happen. A leak, a misconfiguration, a moment of carelessness-and your real location is exposed. Combine that with transaction timestamps, and you’ve got a digital fingerprint.

Even small actions matter. A dusting attack might sound like a joke-a hacker sends you 0.00001 BTC just to see what you do with it. But if you move that dust to consolidate your holdings, you’ve just linked two wallets. That’s all it takes.

Why Offshore Doesn’t Protect You Anymore

Many people assume that if their crypto is held in a wallet registered in the Cayman Islands, Panama, or somewhere with no crypto laws, they’re safe. That’s a myth.

Regulators don’t care where your wallet is. They care where you are. If you’re a UK resident, US citizen, or Australian taxpayer, your government has legal authority over your financial behavior-even if your crypto is stored overseas.

Here’s how it works: most offshore crypto wallets still connect to regulated exchanges. You need to cash out eventually. When you convert crypto to fiat-say, USD, GBP, or AUD-that money flows through a licensed exchange. Those exchanges are required by law to collect your ID, your address, your tax number. If you’re using a fake name or hiding your real location, you’re already in violation.

Worse, those exchanges share data. Thanks to global AML agreements like FATF’s Travel Rule, financial institutions now exchange transaction details across borders. If you sent $10,000 from a wallet in Singapore to a wallet in Estonia, and then cashed out in Germany, all three countries can see that flow. Your "offshore" account isn’t offshore anymore-it’s on a global ledger.

And it’s not just about money. If you’re using crypto to avoid taxes, evade sanctions, or fund illegal activity, you’re not just breaking rules-you’re breaking laws with real prison sentences attached.

The Legal Consequences Are Real-and Getting Harsher

In the United States, violating the Bank Secrecy Act by failing to report offshore crypto holdings can lead to fines up to $500,000 or twice the value of the transaction, whichever is greater. Repeat offenses? Up to 10 years in prison.

The UK’s HMRC treats crypto like any other asset. If you don’t declare gains from offshore crypto trades, you face penalties of up to 200% of the tax owed, plus potential criminal prosecution. In 2023, HMRC launched a targeted crypto compliance campaign, sending letters to over 30,000 UK residents suspected of undeclared crypto income.

Australia’s AUSTRAC has been even more aggressive. In 2024, they fined a Sydney-based crypto trader $1.2 million for using offshore wallets to evade reporting requirements. The trader claimed ignorance-but the court ruled that ignorance isn’t a defense when tools to comply are widely available.

Asset forfeiture is now standard. If authorities believe your crypto was used in illegal activity-even if you didn’t know it-they can seize it. No conviction needed. Just suspicion. And once seized, getting it back is nearly impossible.

And it’s not just Western countries. Singapore, Japan, South Korea, and even the UAE now have strict crypto reporting rules. If you’re moving crypto between jurisdictions to avoid detection, you’re playing a game where every move is watched.

A defendant in court facing robotic regulators, with blockchain maps and seized crypto wallets floating in the background.

What Happens When You’re Caught

There’s no warning. No first-time offense exception. If you’re flagged, you’ll get a letter from a tax authority or financial regulator. It might look official. It might look like spam. But it’s not.

Here’s what usually follows:

  1. Your bank or exchange freezes your accounts.
  2. You’re asked to provide proof of the source of your crypto funds.
  3. If you can’t prove it legally, you’re labeled a high-risk user.
  4. Your name goes into a financial intelligence database.
  5. Future loans, mortgages, or business licenses get denied.
  6. Eventually, criminal charges may follow.

One real case from 2024 involved a Canadian man who used a mix of offshore wallets and privacy coins to hide $2.3 million in crypto gains. He thought he was clever. He wasn’t. Blockchain analytics linked his wallets to a darknet marketplace. He was arrested, charged with tax evasion and money laundering, and sentenced to 3 years in prison. His crypto was seized. His passport was revoked.

What You Should Do Instead

The goal isn’t to hide your crypto. It’s to manage it legally.

If you hold crypto offshore:

  • Declare it on your tax return. Most countries allow you to report foreign crypto holdings using standard forms.
  • Use only regulated exchanges that comply with KYC/AML rules. Avoid unlicensed platforms.
  • Keep records of every transaction: date, amount, wallet addresses, purpose.
  • Don’t use mixers, tumblers, or privacy coins unless you’re prepared for the legal fallout.
  • Consult a tax professional who understands crypto regulations in your country.

There’s no shame in paying taxes on crypto. What’s shameful is risking your freedom, your assets, and your future over a short-term illusion of anonymity.

A man filing crypto tax forms as a crumbling 'offshore anonymity' fortress collapses behind him.

Why This Will Only Get Harder

The tech to track crypto is getting smarter. AI now scans millions of transactions per second. Governments are sharing data faster than ever. In 2025, the EU launched its Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework (CARF), which will automatically exchange crypto transaction data between 45 countries.

Soon, your crypto activity will be visible to your home government even if you never touch a regulated exchange. Wallets connected to DeFi protocols, NFT marketplaces, or staking platforms are now being monitored. Every interaction leaves a trace.

Offshore crypto accounts aren’t a loophole anymore. They’re a liability. And the people who still believe they can hide in plain sight? They’re not getting richer. They’re getting prosecuted.

Can I use a VPN to hide my crypto transactions?

No. While a VPN hides your IP address, it doesn’t hide your blockchain activity. Every crypto transaction is recorded on a public ledger. Investigators don’t need your IP to trace your wallet-they just need your transaction history. If you reuse addresses, send funds to known mixers, or cash out through regulated exchanges, your identity can still be linked to those wallets. A VPN adds no real protection against blockchain analysis.

Are privacy coins like Monero safer for offshore accounts?

Not anymore. While Monero and Zcash offer stronger privacy than Bitcoin or Ethereum, they’re still traceable under certain conditions. Regulators now monitor known Monero addresses linked to exchanges and darknet markets. In 2023, the FATF added Monero to its list of high-risk assets. Many exchanges have stopped supporting it entirely. Using privacy coins raises red flags and increases scrutiny, not reduces it.

What if I inherited crypto from someone overseas?

You still need to declare it. Inheritance doesn’t exempt you from reporting. Most countries treat inherited crypto as taxable income or capital gain. Keep documentation of the transfer, the wallet address, and the value at the time of inheritance. If you don’t, tax authorities may assume you’re hiding assets-and treat you as a deliberate evader.

Can I just delete my offshore crypto wallet and pretend it never existed?

No. Deleting a wallet doesn’t erase the blockchain history. Every transaction you made is permanently recorded. If you previously used that wallet to interact with regulated exchanges, your identity is already tied to it. Authorities can still trace past transactions, even if the wallet is empty. Destroying the wallet looks like an attempt to destroy evidence-and that’s a criminal offense in many jurisdictions.

Is it legal to hold crypto in a foreign wallet if I report it?

Yes, absolutely. Holding crypto in an offshore wallet is not illegal if you report it properly. Many people use foreign wallets for legitimate reasons: lower fees, better privacy features, or access to global markets. The problem isn’t the location-it’s the secrecy. As long as you’re transparent with your tax authority and follow reporting rules, you’re compliant. The goal isn’t to hide your crypto. It’s to manage it legally.

Final Warning

The era of anonymous offshore crypto is over. The tools to find you are here. The laws are clear. The punishments are severe. What you thought was a loophole is now a trap. If you’re holding crypto offshore and haven’t declared it, the clock is ticking. The smart move isn’t to dig deeper into obfuscation. It’s to come clean, get compliant, and move forward without fear.

Related Posts

29 Comments

  • Image placeholder

    Allison Doumith

    November 6, 2025 AT 04:36

    So we're just supposed to trust the state with our money now? 😔
    Like, I get the law, but when the system's rigged, why should I play by its rules?
    I'm not hiding to cheat-I'm hiding because I don't trust them to not steal it anyway.
    They monitor everything. They track your coffee purchases. Why is crypto different?
    It's not about legality. It's about autonomy.
    They call it tax evasion. I call it self-defense.
    And now they want to jail me for using tech that's supposed to be free?
    Who wrote this article? A government contractor?
    I'm not scared of fines. I'm scared of what comes after.
    They'll take my car next. Then my house. Then my voice.
    And I'm supposed to just say 'yes sir' while they empty my wallet?
    That's not compliance. That's surrender.
    And surrender is the only thing worse than prison.
    So yeah. I'll keep my crypto offshore.
    And if they come for me? I'll meet them with a smile.
    Because I already lost everything they could take.
    And I'm still free.
    That's the real crime here.
    Not the crypto. The control.

  • Image placeholder

    Scot Henry

    November 6, 2025 AT 06:24

    bro i just want to buy a house one day and this whole thing is stressing me out
    like i know i should report it but i dont even know how
    and now im scared to even cash out
    what if i mess up and get locked up??

  • Image placeholder

    Sunidhi Arakere

    November 8, 2025 AT 01:20

    This is very serious topic. I live in India. We also have strict rules now. Many people are confused. I think everyone should talk to expert before doing anything.

  • Image placeholder

    Vivian Efthimiopoulou

    November 8, 2025 AT 09:13

    Let us not mistake compliance for capitulation.
    What is being demanded is not submission to tyranny-but accountability to civilization.
    Every transaction, every wallet, every blockchain signature is a thread in the tapestry of human economic life.
    To obscure that thread is not an act of rebellion-it is an act of isolation.
    And isolation from the legal economy is not freedom-it is exile.
    Imagine a society where every citizen is required to declare their wealth, not because they are suspected, but because they are responsible.
    That is not oppression-it is maturity.
    We do not hide our bank accounts. We do not obscure our real estate. We do not launder our income through shell companies.
    So why should crypto be any different?
    The blockchain is not the enemy. The secrecy is.
    True innovation does not hide. It illuminates.
    And if we are to build a future where technology serves humanity-not subverts it-then transparency is not optional.
    It is sacred.
    So yes-declare your holdings.
    Pay your taxes.
    And let your conscience be your only ledger.
    Because in the end, the only prison that matters is the one you build inside your own mind.
    And that prison has no key.
    Only truth.

  • Image placeholder

    Angie Martin-Schwarze

    November 8, 2025 AT 09:17

    i just deleted my wallet and pretended it never happened... but now i keep dreaming about blockchain stuff and wake up in a cold sweat
    what if they still know??
    i didnt even use mixers but i reused an address once and now i think every notification is from the irs
    why does this feel like i did something wrong??
    im not even rich... just got lucky with airdrops
    now i feel like a criminal
    help

  • Image placeholder

    Fred Kärblane

    November 9, 2025 AT 07:35

    Let’s get real-offshore crypto was a beta phase. Now we’re in production.
    Regulators aren’t playing games-they’ve got AI crawling every UTXO, every DeFi interaction, every NFT mint.
    You think you’re anonymous? Your wallet’s got a LinkedIn profile now.
    And if you’re still using Tornado Cash? Bro, you’re not a hacker-you’re a walking compliance ticket.
    The Travel Rule? It’s not a suggestion. It’s a global sync.
    Every exchange, every KYC, every fiat on-ramp is a checkpoint.
    And guess what? Your ‘private’ wallet just pinged a regulated node in Singapore last Tuesday.
    They don’t need your IP. They need your on-chain fingerprint.
    So stop pretending you’re a crypto ninja.
    You’re just a guy with a wallet and a bad habit.
    Time to upgrade your strategy.
    Compliance isn’t weakness.
    It’s your new edge.

  • Image placeholder

    Janna Preston

    November 11, 2025 AT 02:39

    So if I inherited crypto from my uncle in Germany, I have to report it even if I never touched it?
    What if I didn’t even know it existed until after he passed?
    Is that still illegal?
    And what if I didn’t sell it-just kept it in a wallet?
    Do I still owe taxes on something I didn’t earn?
    I’m so confused.
    Can someone explain this like I’m 10?

  • Image placeholder

    Meagan Wristen

    November 11, 2025 AT 15:46

    I just want to say thank you for writing this. I know it’s scary.
    But you’re not alone.
    So many of us are terrified-of taxes, of being judged, of losing everything.
    But here’s the thing: you don’t have to face it alone.
    There are accountants who specialize in crypto.
    There are communities that help you file correctly.
    And there’s peace in doing the right thing-even when it’s hard.
    I used to hide my crypto too.
    Then I got brave.
    Declared it.
    And guess what?
    Nothing bad happened.
    My taxes went up-but so did my sleep.
    And that’s worth more than any anonymous wallet.
    You’ve got this.
    And I’m here if you need help figuring it out.
    Really.
    Just DM me.
    No judgment.

  • Image placeholder

    Becca Robins

    November 12, 2025 AT 04:55

    so like... i just bought some solana with my tax refund and now i'm scared to even look at my wallet
    my cat sat on my keyboard and i think i sent 0.1 to a mixer
    idk what happened
    im gonna be arrested for this aren't i?? 😭😭😭
    also why does everyone act like this is normal??
    its 2025 and we're still being told what to do with our money??
    so much rage

  • Image placeholder

    Alexa Huffman

    November 12, 2025 AT 19:28

    I’ve been holding crypto in a Swiss wallet for 3 years and declared every gain. No issues.
    It’s not about where you hold it-it’s about whether you’re honest.
    My accountant says the IRS doesn’t care about offshore wallets-they care about unreported income.
    So if you’re transparent, you’re fine.
    It’s the secrecy that gets you.
    Not the location.
    And honestly? Reporting it feels better than hiding.
    Like you’re not lying to yourself anymore.
    Try it. You might like it.

  • Image placeholder

    gerald buddiman

    November 14, 2025 AT 15:02

    Okay-can we just pause for a second?
    They’re saying if you use a mixer-even once-you’re flagged?
    But what if you didn’t know it was sanctioned?
    What if you just clicked a link and it auto-swapped?
    What if you’re just a normal person who doesn’t know the difference between a tumbler and a bridge?
    And now you’re on a watchlist?
    That’s not justice.
    That’s a trap.
    They set up the system to fail you.
    Then they punish you for falling.
    And now they call you a criminal?
    That’s not law.
    That’s psychological warfare.
    And I’m not okay with it.

  • Image placeholder

    Arjun Ullas

    November 15, 2025 AT 12:18

    Regulatory compliance is not optional in the modern financial ecosystem. The global financial architecture is now fully interconnected. The FATF Travel Rule, CARF, and AML/KYC protocols are not suggestions-they are binding international obligations. Any attempt to circumvent these mechanisms constitutes a material breach of global financial norms. The consequences are not hypothetical-they are codified in statutes across jurisdictions. It is not a matter of opinion. It is a matter of law. The onus is on the individual to ensure compliance. Ignorance is not a defense. Responsibility is non-negotiable.

  • Image placeholder

    Steven Lam

    November 16, 2025 AT 10:09

    Who cares if they catch you
    you think they care about your crypto
    they just want control
    they want you to beg for permission to own your own money
    that’s the real crime
    not the wallet
    the fear
    and you’re feeding it by reading this
    and following the rules
    pathetic

  • Image placeholder

    Noah Roelofsn

    November 16, 2025 AT 17:48

    Let me paint you a picture.
    You’re not hiding crypto.
    You’re hiding from yourself.
    Every address you reuse, every mixer you touch, every offshore wallet you open-it’s not a shield.
    It’s a mirror.
    And what it reflects is fear.
    Fear of being seen.
    Fear of being taxed.
    Fear of being held accountable.
    But here’s the truth: the blockchain doesn’t care if you’re scared.
    It just records.
    And one day, you’ll wake up and realize the only thing you’ve locked away isn’t your money.
    It’s your freedom.
    Because true autonomy isn’t found in anonymity.
    It’s found in owning your choices.
    Even the messy ones.
    Even the taxable ones.
    So stop running.
    Start owning.
    Your future self will thank you.

  • Image placeholder

    Sierra Rustami

    November 17, 2025 AT 23:46

    Americans are weak.
    They let the government steal their money.
    Real men keep crypto offshore.
    Real men don’t file taxes.
    Real men don’t cry when their wallets get seized.
    They laugh.
    And then they buy more.

  • Image placeholder

    Glen Meyer

    November 18, 2025 AT 19:32

    They want you to think you’re being hunted.
    But you’re not.
    You’re being trained.
    They don’t want to catch you.
    They want you to become them.
    To obey.
    To report.
    To surrender.
    And the moment you do?
    You become part of the machine.
    And then you’ll be the one telling others to comply.
    That’s the real prison.
    Not the cell.
    The mindset.

  • Image placeholder

    Christopher Evans

    November 19, 2025 AT 18:29

    While the article presents a compelling case regarding regulatory compliance, it is essential to acknowledge that the legal landscape surrounding cryptocurrency remains in a state of flux. The application of existing financial statutes to decentralized systems presents interpretive challenges. Moreover, the unilateral enforcement of extraterritorial jurisdiction raises legitimate questions regarding sovereignty and due process. Caution, therefore, is warranted-not as an endorsement of evasion, but as a call for rigorous legal counsel before any action is taken. The stakes are high, and the rules are not yet fully settled.

  • Image placeholder

    Ryan McCarthy

    November 21, 2025 AT 14:54

    I used to be scared too.
    Then I talked to a crypto-savvy CPA.
    Turns out, I owed $1,200.
    Paid it.
    Filed everything.
    Got a confirmation email.
    And guess what?
    I felt lighter.
    Like I could finally breathe.
    It’s not about being perfect.
    It’s about being honest.
    And if you’re reading this?
    You’re already on the right path.
    Take the next step.
    You’ve got this.

  • Image placeholder

    Abelard Rocker

    November 21, 2025 AT 17:14

    Let me tell you what they don’t want you to know.
    They’re not after your crypto.
    They’re after your soul.
    They’ve been building this for decades.
    First, they took cash.
    Then they took privacy.
    Then they took anonymity.
    Now they want your blockchain identity.
    Every transaction.
    Every swap.
    Every NFT you mint.
    Every DeFi pool you join.
    They’re turning the entire internet into a bank ledger.
    And you? You’re just a data point.
    A decimal.
    A line item.
    They don’t care if you’re guilty.
    They care if you’re controllable.
    So when they say ‘declare your assets’?
    What they really mean is:
    ‘Hand over your autonomy.’
    And you’re handing it to them.
    With a smile.
    And a tax form.
    And a sigh.
    And a ‘yes sir’.
    And you wonder why the world feels so heavy.
    It’s because you gave them the keys.
    And now you’re living in their house.
    And they’ve changed the locks.
    And you’re the one who gave them the password.

  • Image placeholder

    Hope Aubrey

    November 22, 2025 AT 00:44

    Okay but why is everyone acting like this is new?
    I’ve been reporting my crypto since 2017.
    It’s not that hard.
    And if you’re worried about jail?
    Then maybe you shouldn’t have used Tornado Cash.
    And if you’re still using it?
    …you’re not a rebel.
    You’re a liability.
    And honestly?
    It’s embarrassing.
    Just file your taxes.
    It’s not that hard.
    And stop pretending you’re some crypto anarchist.
    You’re just bad with money.
    And now you’re mad because the world caught up.
    Grow up.

  • Image placeholder

    andrew seeby

    November 23, 2025 AT 00:54

    bro i just cashed out $5k and now i’m sweating
    my wallet was offshore
    i didn’t use a mixer
    i just sent it straight to coinbase
    did i just get caught??
    should i run??
    😭😭😭
    my dog is looking at me funny

  • Image placeholder

    Pranjali Dattatraya Upadhye

    November 23, 2025 AT 12:22

    Wow, this is really detailed! I think everyone should read this. In India, we are also learning about crypto taxes. It’s not easy, but we must follow the rules. Maybe we can make a group to help each other? I know some people who are scared. We can help them. No one should feel alone. 😊

  • Image placeholder

    Kyung-Ran Koh

    November 24, 2025 AT 01:52

    If you are holding cryptocurrency offshore, you are not inherently violating any law.
    However, the failure to report income, gains, or assets to your home country’s tax authority constitutes a breach of fiduciary duty and statutory obligation.
    Regulatory compliance is not an option-it is a moral and legal imperative.
    Every blockchain transaction is immutable, traceable, and auditable.
    Therefore, the act of concealment is not merely imprudent-it is indefensible.
    Consult a qualified tax advisor immediately.
    Do not delay.
    Your future self will thank you.
    And if you need help navigating the process?
    I am here.
    No judgment.
    Just support.

  • Image placeholder

    Missy Simpson

    November 24, 2025 AT 23:06

    i just found out my uncle left me 10 btc and i didn’t even know it existed until last week
    i’m so scared i’m gonna mess up
    but i’m gonna try
    i’m gonna call a tax person
    i’m gonna report it
    even if i cry the whole time
    thank you for this post
    i feel less alone now 💙

  • Image placeholder

    Tara R

    November 26, 2025 AT 11:54

    The notion that one should comply with arbitrary regulatory frameworks is the hallmark of a passive citizenry.
    Compliance is not virtue.
    It is capitulation.
    And those who celebrate it are not prudent-they are programmed.
    Blockchain was designed to escape the very systems you now beg to join.
    So why do you weep when they catch you?
    Because you never believed in the technology.
    Only in the illusion of control.
    And now you are its slave.
    Well done.

  • Image placeholder

    Matthew Gonzalez

    November 26, 2025 AT 19:23

    What if the real question isn’t whether you can hide your crypto?
    But whether you should want to?
    Because the moment you choose secrecy over transparency,
    you’re not choosing freedom.
    You’re choosing isolation.
    And isolation from the system doesn’t make you free.
    It makes you irrelevant.
    And in a world that’s becoming more connected,
    irrelevance is the new poverty.
    So maybe the real risk isn’t jail.
    Maybe it’s becoming invisible.
    To your family.
    To your community.
    To yourself.

  • Image placeholder

    Allison Doumith

    November 27, 2025 AT 11:22

    You think I care about being relevant?
    I care about being alive.
    And the system doesn’t want me alive.
    It wants me compliant.
    It wants me quiet.
    It wants me to smile while they take my money.
    So no.
    I won’t be relevant.
    I’ll be gone.
    And when they come looking for me?
    They’ll find my wallet.
    Empty.
    And my name.
    On a list.
    But not my voice.
    Not my soul.
    That’s still mine.
    And they’ll never take that.

  • Image placeholder

    Meagan Wristen

    November 28, 2025 AT 16:16

    Hey-I read your comment.
    And I’m not here to judge.
    But I want you to know-your voice matters.
    Even if the system doesn’t hear it.
    Even if they take your wallet.
    Even if they come for you.
    You’re not alone.
    There are people who see you.
    And they’re not scared.
    They’re just waiting for you to come back.
    When you’re ready.
    I’ll be here.
    No rush.
    No pressure.
    Just love.

  • Image placeholder

    Noah Roelofsn

    November 29, 2025 AT 06:31

    That’s the thing no one tells you.
    The blockchain doesn’t erase.
    But you? You can.
    Not your past.
    But your fear.
    You don’t have to be perfect.
    Just honest.
    And if you’re ready?
    Start with one transaction.
    One declaration.
    One step.
    And then breathe.
    Because the only thing harder than hiding?
    Is living with the lie.

Write a comment

Your email address will not be published